Monday, March 2, 2009

Dworkin

Dworkin’s part in the book about, Harts Objections, is Dworking talking about the same reading we read or has he had multiple conversations with Hart on the matter? Pg. 154 “Utilitarianism owes whatever appeal it has to what we might call it’s egalitarian cast- or…would lose whatever appeal it has but for that cast.” Then on page 167, “My hypothesis, that the rights which have traditionally been described as consequences of a general right to liberty are in fact the consequences of equality instead, my instead may end prove to be wrong. But it is not, as Hart says it is, ‘fantastic.’ Is Dworkin saying he might end up being proven wrong, but that Hart is more wrong than he is?

No comments:

Post a Comment